世界气功网

从“胡万林”非法行医事件看中医的困境

2022-01-17 14:10:29 admin 阅读(647)

「导读」胡万林是一个未见经传的民间小人物,但由他“非法行医”引发的一系列问题和事件,影响却是相当大的,深远的,不仅全国上下,而且波及世界许多国家和地区。一些人说他是神医,这里不乏中医世家、教授、中医爱好者为他打抱不平;一些人说他是骗子,这里是科学界的主流,说他治死过一些人。到底是怎么回事?我们有必要拨乱反正,实事求是,客观地看待这一个问题。

胡万林是一个未见经传的民间小人物,但由他“非法行医”引发的一系列问题和事件,影响却是相当大的,深远的,不仅全国上下,而且波及世界许多国家和地区。一些人说他是神医,这里不乏中医世家、教授、中医爱好者为他打抱不平;一些人说他是骗子,这里是科学界的主流,说他治死过一些人。到底是怎么回事?我们有必要拨乱反正,实事求是,客观地看待这一个问题。

说他是“神医”并不是空穴来风,事实就在那摆着,胡万林在90年代初期的四五年时间收治过国内外上百万人次的各类患者,其中被治愈的癌症、白血病病患等就有五六千人以上;被他治愈的脑瘫、先天性聋哑等疑难奇症成千上万;胡对治疗糖尿病、艾滋病、戒毒等也有奇招和神奇的疗效。数年时间患者赠送给他的锦旗、匾牌、哈达和感谢信就有10多万件。为此,哈木提监狱也获利颇丰,100多万患者,1000万元的收入,在90年代,这绝对是一个惊人的数据,没有几个名医能够超越他。

说他是”骗子“,当然也有很多证据,比如说他没有系统学过中医,没有行医资格,没有望闻问切,还有很多患者的病没有治好,甚至经他治过以后患者死亡了。主流的科学界就是抓住这些急追猛打,把他关进了监狱。

不过,这对于中医来说是值得商榷的,首先,中医本身根源于哲学,而哲学不是学出来的,而是悟出来的,因此,中医是可以自学成才的,历史的很多大医就没有师承,也是自学的,我们不能因这一点就说没有系统学过中医就成不了中医;其次,行医资格证是西医强加给中医的,中医是以疗效为根本的,而不是那个西医式的证,证也不可能体现中医人的水平,以证取人对中医来说是不合理的。其三,没有望闻问切,中医诊断方法多样,精通任何一门方法都可以精确诊断,并不见得需要所有诊断方法都要学会,比如一些人可以通过人体感应来诊断疾病。其四,一些病人没有治好。由于历史的局限,中医诊断遣方都很模糊,这就注定了疗效的不确定,即使一些大医,也曾经说过,能够治好60%的病人就是水平高的中医,我们不能因为西医治不好某些病就说西医是骗子。其五,一些病人经过他的治疗死亡了。大家都知道中医的现状,正常条件下没有几个找中医的,都是长期西医治不好的疑难病症被迫找中医碰大运的,有些病人本身就是危重病人,死亡的原因多种多样,并不一定都是中医治疗的原因,我们基于中医无力辩驳就把死亡的原因归罪于中医,本身就是不公平的,比如,西医化疗治癌直接死亡的人有的是,可西医没有一点责任,为什么中医就要承担全部责任呢?

至于胡万林的治疗方法,有人说他的方法违背了中医的辩证施治。从某种意义上来说,确实有此之嫌。但不是没有一点理论基础,无非就是他特别注重泻药的使用,泻下也是中医的一种治疗方法,对很多病确实有很好的疗效。历史上中医就有很多门派,比如火神派,什么病都要补阳,胡万林的理论可以称为泻下派,这并没有什么不可。这就如同欧洲曾经风靡几个世纪的放血疗法,什么病都放血,你能说没有副作用吗?你能说没有死过人吗?如果把此都污为伪科学,恐怕是不负责任的态度。

胡万林被判刑的根据就是治死了人,这个逻辑其实非常幼稚。每个大医院天天都在死人,而且都是经过西医治疗以后死的。不过,西医有一套标准,只要按照这个标准,医生没有一点责任。而中医的最大问题就是说不清楚,一旦死了人,就要承担无限的责任,这对中医来说就是灭顶之灾。其实,死不死不是关键,关于在于对于方法的评价,这才有说服力,如果说“收治各类疑难病症120万人,共治愈癌症(其中大多数为晚期患者)6400多例,聋哑等先天性残疾5420多人,牛皮癣、硬皮病等2200多人,心血管病7000多人,甲亢1000多人,各类风湿病1200多人,其他如帕金森氏症、骨质增生、前列腺肥大、不育症、胃、肠、胆、脾、肾、眼(高度近视、青光眼、斜视、弱视等)、喉、腰、腿等疾病以及低烧、脱发等多达数十万人”,这么大的量,如果只死一百来个人,我看北京协和医院大约也不止死这个数字。因此,我们要批判中医的时候,不要用变色的眼睛来看。

客观地说,胡万林确实在理论上有局限,泻下确实对一些疾病有很好的疗效,但并不是所有的病都可以这样去治,”热者寒之,寒者热之“的中医理论大家都懂,缓和了人的体质偏性对人都是良药,加剧了人的体质偏性都是毒药。胡万林的问题就在于对于一些寒性体质也用这种方法,加剧了体质偏性,更重要的是,盲硝寒性较大,用它对一些体质敏感的人确实伤害较大,不能说不能用,只能说中病即止,还需要马上弥补这种伤害,这才是真正的中医之道。

胡万林事件可以看出中医在整个医疗界的尴尬。中医缺乏应有的标准,说你错你就错,不错也错。比如,什么才是合格中医,用证还是用疗效来进行评价?中医治疗出了问题,如何认定责任?象现在这样,一旦出了事故,中医都是全责,这让所有中医都不敢大胆治病,只会用那些不痛不痒偏性较小的药,虽然风险小了,但疗效却大大降低了,中医的优势也就显现不出来了。

更重要的是,在中医内在的科学性没有得到科学主流的承认之前,对中医的所有管理基本上都是按照西医标准,让所有中医削足适履,这只会让中医不断走向灭亡。比如,用医师资格证制度来管理,所有民间中医都是非法行医,用《医药管理法》来管理,所有中医遣方用药都是非法制药,用西医治病的标准来管理,中医治病都是不科学的,出了问题责任都可以归罪于中医。在这种环境下,中医恐怕很难再有活路。

接口页面--全局数据:

site-> {"id":1,"name":"世界气功网","domain":"www.shijieqigong.com","email":"867528315@qq.com","wx":null,"icp":null,"code":"","json":"","title":"世界气功网官网","keywords":"世界气功网|气功|养生|动功|静功|内功|外功|吐纳|导引|止观","description":"世界气功网致力于传播正宗中国气功文化和养生知识,提供最新气功新闻与信息。在这里,您可以学习到各类气功技巧,如止观、静功、动功、内功、外功,呼吸吐纳等,以及养生、健康长寿等相关知识。弘扬健康文化,共享气功魅力!","createdAt":null,"updatedAt":"2023-11-20T11:30:24.000Z","template":null,"appid":null,"secret":null}

111-->

nav-> [{"id":1,"pid":0,"name":"气功新闻","pinyin":"qigongxinwen","path":"/qigongxinwen","sort":1,"target":"0","status":"0","list_view":"list.html","article_view":"article.html","seo_title":"","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"","type":"0"},{"id":24,"pid":23,"name":"内劲一指禅","pinyin":"neijinyizhichan","path":"/chuantonggongfa/neijinyizhichan","sort":1,"target":"0","status":"0","list_view":"list.html","article_view":"article.html","seo_title":"","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"","type":"0"},{"id":25,"pid":23,"name":"大雁功","pinyin":"dayangong","path":"/chuantonggongfa/dayangong","sort":1,"target":"0","status":"0","list_view":"list.html","article_view":"article.html","seo_title":"","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"","type":"0"},{"id":26,"pid":23,"name":" 郭林新气功","pinyin":"guolinxinqigong","path":"/chuantonggongfa/guolinxinqigong","sort":1,"target":"0","status":"0","list_view":"list.html","article_view":"article.html","seo_title":"","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"","type":"0"},{"id":27,"pid":23,"name":" 内养功","pinyin":"neiyanggong","path":"/chuantonggongfa/neiyanggong","sort":1,"target":"0","status":"0","list_view":"list.html","article_view":"article.html","seo_title":"","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"","type":"0"},{"id":28,"pid":23,"name":"站桩功","pinyin":"zhanzhuanggong","path":"/chuantonggongfa/zhanzhuanggong","sort":1,"target":"0","status":"0","list_view":"list.html","article_view":"article.html","seo_title":"","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"","type":"0"},{"id":29,"pid":23,"name":" 天柱养生功","pinyin":"tianzhuyangshenggong","path":"/chuantonggongfa/tianzhuyangshenggong","sort":1,"target":"0","status":"0","list_view":"list.html","article_view":"article.html","seo_title":"","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"","type":"0"},{"id":2,"pid":0,"name":"学术交流","pinyin":"xueshujiaoliu","path":"/xueshujiaoliu","sort":2,"target":"0","status":"0","list_view":"list.html","article_view":"article.html","seo_title":"","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"","type":"0"},{"id":3,"pid":0,"name":"体育气功","pinyin":"tiyuqigong","path":"/tiyuqigong","sort":3,"target":"0","status":"0","list_view":"list.html","article_view":"article.html","seo_title":"","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"","type":"0"},{"id":4,"pid":0,"name":"医学气功","pinyin":"yixueqigong","path":"/yixueqigong","sort":4,"target":"0","status":"0","list_view":"list.html","article_view":"article.html","seo_title":"","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"","type":"0"},{"id":5,"pid":0,"name":"养生气功","pinyin":"yangshengqigong","path":"/yangshengqigong","sort":5,"target":"0","status":"0","list_view":"list.html","article_view":"article.html","seo_title":"","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"","type":"0"},{"id":8,"pid":0,"name":"气功医案","pinyin":"qigongyian","path":"/qigongyian","sort":8,"target":"0","status":"0","list_view":"list.html","article_view":"article.html","seo_title":"","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"","type":"0"},{"id":9,"pid":0,"name":"气功与书画","pinyin":"qigongyushuhua","path":"/qigongyushuhua","sort":9,"target":"0","status":"0","list_view":"list.html","article_view":"article.html","seo_title":"","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"","type":"0"},{"id":10,"pid":0,"name":"气功人物","pinyin":"qigongrenwu","path":"/qigongrenwu","sort":10,"target":"0","status":"0","list_view":"list.html","article_view":"article.html","seo_title":"","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"","type":"0"},{"id":11,"pid":0,"name":"人体科学","pinyin":"rentikexue","path":"/rentikexue","sort":11,"target":"0","status":"0","list_view":"list.html","article_view":"article.html","seo_title":"","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"","type":"0"},{"id":12,"pid":0,"name":"功法实践","pinyin":"gongfashijian","path":"/gongfashijian","sort":12,"target":"0","status":"0","list_view":"list.html","article_view":"article.html","seo_title":"","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"","type":"0"},{"id":13,"pid":0,"name":"注意事项","pinyin":"zhuyishixiang","path":"/zhuyishixiang","sort":13,"target":"0","status":"0","list_view":"list.html","article_view":"article.html","seo_title":"","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"","type":"0"},{"id":14,"pid":0,"name":"气功培训","pinyin":"qigongpeixun","path":"/qigongpeixun","sort":14,"target":"0","status":"0","list_view":"list.html","article_view":"article.html","seo_title":"","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"","type":"0"},{"id":15,"pid":0,"name":"气功资料","pinyin":"qigongziliao","path":"/qigongziliao","sort":15,"target":"0","status":"0","list_view":"list.html","article_view":"article.html","seo_title":"","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"","type":"0"},{"id":16,"pid":0,"name":"气功百科","pinyin":"qigongbaike","path":"/qigongbaike","sort":16,"target":"0","status":"0","list_view":"list.html","article_view":"article.html","seo_title":"","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"","type":"0"},{"id":6,"pid":0,"name":"太 极","pinyin":"taiji","path":"/taiji","sort":17,"target":"0","status":"0","list_view":"list.html","article_view":"article.html","seo_title":"","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"","type":"0"},{"id":23,"pid":0,"name":"传统功法","pinyin":"chuantonggongfa","path":"/chuantonggongfa","sort":18,"target":"0","status":"0","list_view":"list.html","article_view":"article.html","seo_title":"","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"","type":"0"},{"id":30,"pid":0,"name":"气功博物馆","pinyin":"qigongbowuguan","path":"/qigongbowuguan","sort":27,"target":"0","status":"0","list_view":"list.html","article_view":"article.html","seo_title":"","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"","type":"0"},{"id":31,"pid":0,"name":"气功术语","pinyin":"qigongshuyu","path":"/qigongshuyu","sort":28,"target":"0","status":"0","list_view":"list.html","article_view":"article.html","seo_title":"","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"","type":"0"},{"id":32,"pid":0,"name":"李春生文集","pinyin":"lichunshengwenji","path":"/lichunshengwenji","sort":29,"target":"0","status":"1","list_view":"list.html","article_view":"article.html","seo_title":"","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"","type":"0"}]

category-> [{"id":1,"pid":0,"name":"气功新闻","pinyin":"qigongxinwen","path":"/qigongxinwen","sort":1,"target":"0","status":"0","list_view":"list.html","article_view":"article.html","seo_title":"","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"","type":"0"},{"id":24,"pid":23,"name":"内劲一指禅","pinyin":"neijinyizhichan","path":"/chuantonggongfa/neijinyizhichan","sort":1,"target":"0","status":"0","list_view":"list.html","article_view":"article.html","seo_title":"","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"","type":"0"},{"id":25,"pid":23,"name":"大雁功","pinyin":"dayangong","path":"/chuantonggongfa/dayangong","sort":1,"target":"0","status":"0","list_view":"list.html","article_view":"article.html","seo_title":"","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"","type":"0"},{"id":26,"pid":23,"name":" 郭林新气功","pinyin":"guolinxinqigong","path":"/chuantonggongfa/guolinxinqigong","sort":1,"target":"0","status":"0","list_view":"list.html","article_view":"article.html","seo_title":"","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"","type":"0"},{"id":27,"pid":23,"name":" 内养功","pinyin":"neiyanggong","path":"/chuantonggongfa/neiyanggong","sort":1,"target":"0","status":"0","list_view":"list.html","article_view":"article.html","seo_title":"","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"","type":"0"},{"id":28,"pid":23,"name":"站桩功","pinyin":"zhanzhuanggong","path":"/chuantonggongfa/zhanzhuanggong","sort":1,"target":"0","status":"0","list_view":"list.html","article_view":"article.html","seo_title":"","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"","type":"0"},{"id":29,"pid":23,"name":" 天柱养生功","pinyin":"tianzhuyangshenggong","path":"/chuantonggongfa/tianzhuyangshenggong","sort":1,"target":"0","status":"0","list_view":"list.html","article_view":"article.html","seo_title":"","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"","type":"0"},{"id":2,"pid":0,"name":"学术交流","pinyin":"xueshujiaoliu","path":"/xueshujiaoliu","sort":2,"target":"0","status":"0","list_view":"list.html","article_view":"article.html","seo_title":"","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"","type":"0"},{"id":3,"pid":0,"name":"体育气功","pinyin":"tiyuqigong","path":"/tiyuqigong","sort":3,"target":"0","status":"0","list_view":"list.html","article_view":"article.html","seo_title":"","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"","type":"0"},{"id":4,"pid":0,"name":"医学气功","pinyin":"yixueqigong","path":"/yixueqigong","sort":4,"target":"0","status":"0","list_view":"list.html","article_view":"article.html","seo_title":"","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"","type":"0"},{"id":5,"pid":0,"name":"养生气功","pinyin":"yangshengqigong","path":"/yangshengqigong","sort":5,"target":"0","status":"0","list_view":"list.html","article_view":"article.html","seo_title":"","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"","type":"0"},{"id":8,"pid":0,"name":"气功医案","pinyin":"qigongyian","path":"/qigongyian","sort":8,"target":"0","status":"0","list_view":"list.html","article_view":"article.html","seo_title":"","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"","type":"0"},{"id":9,"pid":0,"name":"气功与书画","pinyin":"qigongyushuhua","path":"/qigongyushuhua","sort":9,"target":"0","status":"0","list_view":"list.html","article_view":"article.html","seo_title":"","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"","type":"0"},{"id":10,"pid":0,"name":"气功人物","pinyin":"qigongrenwu","path":"/qigongrenwu","sort":10,"target":"0","status":"0","list_view":"list.html","article_view":"article.html","seo_title":"","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"","type":"0"},{"id":11,"pid":0,"name":"人体科学","pinyin":"rentikexue","path":"/rentikexue","sort":11,"target":"0","status":"0","list_view":"list.html","article_view":"article.html","seo_title":"","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"","type":"0"},{"id":12,"pid":0,"name":"功法实践","pinyin":"gongfashijian","path":"/gongfashijian","sort":12,"target":"0","status":"0","list_view":"list.html","article_view":"article.html","seo_title":"","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"","type":"0"},{"id":13,"pid":0,"name":"注意事项","pinyin":"zhuyishixiang","path":"/zhuyishixiang","sort":13,"target":"0","status":"0","list_view":"list.html","article_view":"article.html","seo_title":"","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"","type":"0"},{"id":14,"pid":0,"name":"气功培训","pinyin":"qigongpeixun","path":"/qigongpeixun","sort":14,"target":"0","status":"0","list_view":"list.html","article_view":"article.html","seo_title":"","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"","type":"0"},{"id":15,"pid":0,"name":"气功资料","pinyin":"qigongziliao","path":"/qigongziliao","sort":15,"target":"0","status":"0","list_view":"list.html","article_view":"article.html","seo_title":"","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"","type":"0"},{"id":16,"pid":0,"name":"气功百科","pinyin":"qigongbaike","path":"/qigongbaike","sort":16,"target":"0","status":"0","list_view":"list.html","article_view":"article.html","seo_title":"","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"","type":"0"},{"id":6,"pid":0,"name":"太 极","pinyin":"taiji","path":"/taiji","sort":17,"target":"0","status":"0","list_view":"list.html","article_view":"article.html","seo_title":"","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"","type":"0"},{"id":23,"pid":0,"name":"传统功法","pinyin":"chuantonggongfa","path":"/chuantonggongfa","sort":18,"target":"0","status":"0","list_view":"list.html","article_view":"article.html","seo_title":"","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"","type":"0"},{"id":30,"pid":0,"name":"气功博物馆","pinyin":"qigongbowuguan","path":"/qigongbowuguan","sort":27,"target":"0","status":"0","list_view":"list.html","article_view":"article.html","seo_title":"","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"","type":"0"},{"id":31,"pid":0,"name":"气功术语","pinyin":"qigongshuyu","path":"/qigongshuyu","sort":28,"target":"0","status":"0","list_view":"list.html","article_view":"article.html","seo_title":"","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"","type":"0"},{"id":32,"pid":0,"name":"李春生文集","pinyin":"lichunshengwenji","path":"/lichunshengwenji","sort":29,"target":"0","status":"1","list_view":"list.html","article_view":"article.html","seo_title":"","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"","type":"0"}]

friendlink-> [{"id":1,"title":"香港日报","link":"http://www.hongkongdaily.net","sort":0,"createdAt":"2023-07-22T14:59:55.000Z"}]

base_url-> /public/template/qigong

frag--->{"home-gjqg":"<p><img src=\"/public/uploads/qigong/20180621-19-20-16_10746_tj.jpg\" class=\"w-p100\" alt=\"\"></p>","home-hjtzx":"<p><img src=\"http://static.hongkongdaily.net/hongkongdaily/upload/2018-05-30/363d6fd4509b27c228fb9ec3deb0bc3e.jpg\" class=\"w-p100\" alt=\"\"></p>","home-sjqgwkt":"<h3 class=\"c-333 f-16 mb-5 mt-5\">世界气功网开通</h3>\n<p class=\"c-666 f-14\"><a href=\"/qigongxinwen/article-8.html\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">世界气功是由世界大健康运动联盟主办,面向世界,弘扬健康养生文化,传播优秀健身方法, 汇聚各国健康养生新信息新成果等信息服务。详情&gt;&gt;</a></p>","jituangongsi":"香港日报集团公司(中国香港)","info":"<p>免责申明:网站内容仅供参考!部分内容来源网络,如有侵犯版权,联系邮箱:867528315@qq.com 技术人员进行删除。</p>","doingCompany":"北京中知紫荆科技有限公司(中国北京)","company":"世界大健康运动联盟主办(中国香港)","xianggangribao":"<p class=\"mb-10 pos-r\"><a href=\"http://static.hongkongdaily.net/hongkongdaily/2014/2021/index.html\"> <img src=\"http://static.hongkongdaily.net/hongkongdaily/2014/2021/img/ad.jpg?v=20220127\" width=\"100%\"> <span class=\"years\">25</span></a></p>","yujia":"<img src=\"/public/uploads/qigong/20180621-19-20-50_18608_yj.jpg\" />","taiji":"<img src=\"/public/uploads/qigong/20180621-19-20-16_10746_tj.jpg\" />","fenglida":"<div style=\"display: flex; margin-top: 5px; justify-content: center; align-items: center; width: 100%; height: 120px; background-image: repeating-linear-gradient(0deg, hsla(208,43%,84%,0.09) 0px, hsla(208,43%,84%,0.09) 1px,transparent 1px, transparent 9px),repeating-linear-gradient(90deg, hsla(208,43%,84%,0.09) 0px, hsla(208,43%,84%,0.09) 1px,transparent 1px, transparent 9px),linear-gradient(90deg, hsl(203,93%,43%),hsl(203,93%,43%));\">\n<div style=\"width: 100px; height: 100px; margin-left: 10px; margin-right: 10px; background-color: rgba(255, 255, 255, 0.96); border-radius: 50%;\"><a href=\"http://static.hongkongdaily.net/hongkongdaily/zhuanti/fenglida/index.html\"><img style=\"width: 100px;\" src=\"http://static.hongkongdaily.net/hongkongdaily/zhuanti/fenglida/img/fenglida.png\" alt=\"\"></a></div>\n<a href=\"http://static.hongkongdaily.net/hongkongdaily/zhuanti/fenglida/index.html\" style=\"flex: 1; font-size: 38px; color: #fff; text-shadow: 0px 4px 3px rgba(0,0,0,0.4), 0px 8px 13px rgba(0,0,0,0.1),0px 18px 23px rgba(0,0,0,0.1);\">隆重纪念冯理达教授诞辰99周年</a></div>","wushaozu":"<div style=\"display: flex; justify-content: center; align-items: center; margin-top: 5px; width: 100%; height: 120px; background-image: repeating-linear-gradient(0deg, hsla(124,22%,97%,0.09) 0px, hsla(124,22%,97%,0.09) 1px,transparent 1px, transparent 11px),repeating-linear-gradient(90deg, hsla(124,22%,97%,0.09) 0px, hsla(124,22%,97%,0.09) 1px,transparent 1px, transparent 11px),linear-gradient(90deg, hsl(202,76%,66%),hsl(202,76%,66%));\">\n<div style=\"width: 100px; height: 100px; margin-left: 10px; margin-right: 10px; background-color: rgba(255, 255, 255, 0.96); border-radius: 50%;\"><a href=\"http://static.hongkongdaily.net/hongkongdaily/zhuanti/wushaozu/index.html\"><img style=\"width: 100px;\" src=\"http://static.hongkongdaily.net/hongkongdaily/zhuanti/wushaozu/img/wushaozu.png\" alt=\"\"></a></div>\n<a href=\"http://static.hongkongdaily.net/hongkongdaily/zhuanti/wushaozu/index.html\" style=\"flex: 1; font-size: 38px; color: #fff; text-shadow: 0px 4px 3px rgba(0,0,0,0.4), 0px 8px 13px rgba(0,0,0,0.1),0px 18px 23px rgba(0,0,0,0.1);\">隆重纪念伍绍祖同志诞辰85周年</a></div>","qianxuesen":"<div style=\"display: flex; margin-top: 10px; justify-content: center; align-items: center; width: 100%; height: 120px; background-image: repeating-linear-gradient(0deg, hsla(208,43%,84%,0.09) 0px, hsla(208,43%,84%,0.09) 1px,transparent 1px, transparent 9px),repeating-linear-gradient(90deg, hsla(208,43%,84%,0.09) 0px, hsla(208,43%,84%,0.09) 1px,transparent 1px, transparent 9px),linear-gradient(90deg, hsl(203,93%,43%),hsl(203,93%,43%));\">\n<div style=\"width: 100px; height: 100px; margin-left: 10px; margin-right: 10px; background-color: rgba(255,255,255,0.8); border-radius: 50%;\"><a href=\"http://static.hongkongdaily.net/hongkongdaily/zhuanti/qianxuesen/index.html\"><img style=\"width: 100px;\" src=\"http://static.hongkongdaily.net/hongkongdaily/zhuanti/qianxuesen/img/qianxuesen.png\" alt=\"\"></a></div>\n<a href=\"http://static.hongkongdaily.net/hongkongdaily/zhuanti/qianxuesen/index.html\" style=\"flex: 1; font-size: 38px; color: #fff; text-shadow: 0px 4px 3px rgba(0,0,0,0.4), 0px 8px 13px rgba(0,0,0,0.1),0px 18px 23px rgba(0,0,0,0.1);\">隆重纪念著名科学家钱学森同志诞辰113周年</a></div>","disanjie":"<p><a href=\"http://static.hongkongdaily.net/hongkongdaily/2014/2023/index.html\"> <img src=\"http://static.hongkongdaily.net/shijieqigong/20210803-20-00-06_10426_banner-small.jpg?v=20211228\" width=\"100%\"> </a></p>"}

tag--->[{"id":4,"name":"pdf","path":"pdf"},{"id":3,"name":"开发工具","path":"devtool"},{"id":2,"name":"js库","path":"jslib"},{"id":1,"name":"cms","path":"cms"}]

-----------

position------>[{"id":1,"pid":0,"name":"气功新闻","pinyin":"qigongxinwen","path":"/qigongxinwen","sort":1,"target":"0","status":"0","list_view":"list.html","article_view":"article.html","seo_title":"","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"","type":"0"}]

navSub------>{"cate":{"id":1,"pid":0,"name":"气功新闻","pinyin":"qigongxinwen","path":"/qigongxinwen","sort":1,"target":"0","status":"0","list_view":"list.html","article_view":"article.html","seo_title":"","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"","type":"0"},"id":1}

article------>{"id":777,"cid":1,"sub_cid":"","title":"从“胡万林”非法行医事件看中医的困境","short_title":"0","tag_id":"","attr":"1,2","seo_title":"0","seo_keywords":"","seo_description":"1","source":"网络","author":"admin","description":"胡万林是一个未见经传的民间小人物,但由他“非法行医”引发的一系列问题和事件,影响却是相当大的,深远的,不仅全国上下,而且波及世界许多国家和地区。一些人说他是神医,这里不乏中医世家、教授、中医爱好者为他打抱不平;一些人说他是骗子,这里是科学界的主流,说他治死过一些人。到底是怎么回事?我们有必要拨乱反正,实事求是,客观地看待这一个问题。","img":"","content":"<p>胡万林是一个未见经传的民间小人物,但由他“非法行医”引发的一系列问题和事件,影响却是相当大的,深远的,不仅全国上下,而且波及世界许多国家和地区。一些人说他是神医,这里不乏中医世家、教授、中医爱好者为他打抱不平;一些人说他是骗子,这里是科学界的主流,说他治死过一些人。到底是怎么回事?我们有必要拨乱反正,实事求是,客观地看待这一个问题。</p><p>说他是“神医”并不是空穴来风,事实就在那摆着,胡万林在90年代初期的四五年时间收治过国内外上百万人次的各类患者,其中被治愈的癌症、白血病病患等就有五六千人以上;被他治愈的脑瘫、先天性聋哑等疑难奇症成千上万;胡对治疗糖尿病、艾滋病、戒毒等也有奇招和神奇的疗效。数年时间患者赠送给他的锦旗、匾牌、哈达和感谢信就有10多万件。为此,哈木提监狱也获利颇丰,100多万患者,1000万元的收入,在90年代,这绝对是一个惊人的数据,没有几个名医能够超越他。</p><p>说他是”骗子“,当然也有很多证据,比如说他没有系统学过中医,没有行医资格,没有望闻问切,还有很多患者的病没有治好,甚至经他治过以后患者死亡了。主流的科学界就是抓住这些急追猛打,把他关进了监狱。</p><p>不过,这对于中医来说是值得商榷的,首先,中医本身根源于哲学,而哲学不是学出来的,而是悟出来的,因此,中医是可以自学成才的,历史的很多大医就没有师承,也是自学的,我们不能因这一点就说没有系统学过中医就成不了中医;其次,行医资格证是西医强加给中医的,中医是以疗效为根本的,而不是那个西医式的证,证也不可能体现中医人的水平,以证取人对中医来说是不合理的。其三,没有望闻问切,中医诊断方法多样,精通任何一门方法都可以精确诊断,并不见得需要所有诊断方法都要学会,比如一些人可以通过人体感应来诊断疾病。其四,一些病人没有治好。由于历史的局限,中医诊断遣方都很模糊,这就注定了疗效的不确定,即使一些大医,也曾经说过,能够治好60%的病人就是水平高的中医,我们不能因为西医治不好某些病就说西医是骗子。其五,一些病人经过他的治疗死亡了。大家都知道中医的现状,正常条件下没有几个找中医的,都是长期西医治不好的疑难病症被迫找中医碰大运的,有些病人本身就是危重病人,死亡的原因多种多样,并不一定都是中医治疗的原因,我们基于中医无力辩驳就把死亡的原因归罪于中医,本身就是不公平的,比如,西医化疗治癌直接死亡的人有的是,可西医没有一点责任,为什么中医就要承担全部责任呢?</p><p>至于胡万林的治疗方法,有人说他的方法违背了中医的辩证施治。从某种意义上来说,确实有此之嫌。但不是没有一点理论基础,无非就是他特别注重泻药的使用,泻下也是中医的一种治疗方法,对很多病确实有很好的疗效。历史上中医就有很多门派,比如火神派,什么病都要补阳,胡万林的理论可以称为泻下派,这并没有什么不可。这就如同欧洲曾经风靡几个世纪的放血疗法,什么病都放血,你能说没有副作用吗?你能说没有死过人吗?如果把此都污为伪科学,恐怕是不负责任的态度。</p><p>胡万林被判刑的根据就是治死了人,这个逻辑其实非常幼稚。每个大医院天天都在死人,而且都是经过西医治疗以后死的。不过,西医有一套标准,只要按照这个标准,医生没有一点责任。而中医的最大问题就是说不清楚,一旦死了人,就要承担无限的责任,这对中医来说就是灭顶之灾。其实,死不死不是关键,关于在于对于方法的评价,这才有说服力,如果说“收治各类疑难病症120万人,共治愈癌症(其中大多数为晚期患者)6400多例,聋哑等先天性残疾5420多人,牛皮癣、硬皮病等2200多人,心血管病7000多人,甲亢1000多人,各类风湿病1200多人,其他如帕金森氏症、骨质增生、前列腺肥大、不育症、胃、肠、胆、脾、肾、眼(高度近视、青光眼、斜视、弱视等)、喉、腰、腿等疾病以及低烧、脱发等多达数十万人”,这么大的量,如果只死一百来个人,我看北京协和医院大约也不止死这个数字。因此,我们要批判中医的时候,不要用变色的眼睛来看。</p><p>客观地说,胡万林确实在理论上有局限,泻下确实对一些疾病有很好的疗效,但并不是所有的病都可以这样去治,”热者寒之,寒者热之“的中医理论大家都懂,缓和了人的体质偏性对人都是良药,加剧了人的体质偏性都是毒药。胡万林的问题就在于对于一些寒性体质也用这种方法,加剧了体质偏性,更重要的是,盲硝寒性较大,用它对一些体质敏感的人确实伤害较大,不能说不能用,只能说中病即止,还需要马上弥补这种伤害,这才是真正的中医之道。</p><p>胡万林事件可以看出中医在整个医疗界的尴尬。中医缺乏应有的标准,说你错你就错,不错也错。比如,什么才是合格中医,用证还是用疗效来进行评价?中医治疗出了问题,如何认定责任?象现在这样,一旦出了事故,中医都是全责,这让所有中医都不敢大胆治病,只会用那些不痛不痒偏性较小的药,虽然风险小了,但疗效却大大降低了,中医的优势也就显现不出来了。</p><p>\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n</p><p>更重要的是,在中医内在的科学性没有得到科学主流的承认之前,对中医的所有管理基本上都是按照西医标准,让所有中医削足适履,这只会让中医不断走向灭亡。比如,用医师资格证制度来管理,所有民间中医都是非法行医,用《医药管理法》来管理,所有中医遣方用药都是非法制药,用西医治病的标准来管理,中医治病都是不科学的,出了问题责任都可以归罪于中医。在这种环境下,中医恐怕很难再有活路。</p>","status":0,"pv":647,"link":"1","createdAt":"2022-01-17 14:10:29","updatedAt":"2024-03-29 13:51:20","field":{},"tags":[]}

article.tags------>[]

news------>[{"id":847,"title":"今天钱学森诞辰112周年!郭周礼:钱老,我永远的贵人","short_title":"","img":"","createdAt":"2023-12-11T03:10:08.000Z","description":"导读:今天(2023年12月11日),是中国航天事业奠基人、国家杰出贡献科学家、两弹一星功勋勋章获得者钱学森教授诞辰112周年纪念日(1911年12月11日—2009年10月31日)。","pinyin":"qigongxinwen","name":"气功新闻","path":"/qigongxinwen"},{"id":846,"title":"香港日报2023-10-18电子版第1-2版","short_title":"","img":null,"createdAt":"2023-10-02T12:22:34.000Z","description":"\n","pinyin":"qigongxinwen","name":"气功新闻","path":"/qigongxinwen"},{"id":845,"title":"香港日报2023-10-18电子版第3-4版","short_title":"","img":null,"createdAt":"2023-10-02T12:21:47.000Z","description":"\n","pinyin":"qigongxinwen","name":"气功新闻","path":"/qigongxinwen"},{"id":844,"title":"香港日报2023-10-18电子版第5-6版","short_title":"","img":null,"createdAt":"2023-10-02T12:21:04.000Z","description":"\n","pinyin":"qigongxinwen","name":"气功新闻","path":"/qigongxinwen"},{"id":843,"title":"香港日报2023-10-18电子版第7-8版","short_title":"","img":null,"createdAt":"2023-10-02T12:19:06.000Z","description":"\n","pinyin":"qigongxinwen","name":"气功新闻","path":"/qigongxinwen"},{"id":841,"title":"香港日报2023-06-18电子版第二版","short_title":"","img":null,"createdAt":"2023-06-17T11:24:16.000Z","description":"","pinyin":"qigongxinwen","name":"气功新闻","path":"/qigongxinwen"},{"id":839,"title":"香港日报2023-06-18电子版第四版","short_title":"","img":null,"createdAt":"2023-06-17T11:23:17.000Z","description":"","pinyin":"qigongxinwen","name":"气功新闻","path":"/qigongxinwen"},{"id":838,"title":"郭周礼主席出席周公庙润德泉圣水采集仪式并讲话","short_title":"","img":"https://p3-sign.toutiaoimg.com/tos-cn-i-qvj2lq49k0/a66e264d07e24f1c823bb63845f867e7~noop.image?_iz=58558&amp;from=article.pc_detail&amp;x-expires=1684845112&amp;x-signature=9c3BFi4%2BEgwATJ564g%2FlTYb6Hyw%3D","createdAt":"2023-05-16T12:49:36.000Z","description":"2023年5月15日,由世界大健康运动联盟发起,首届“五岳和鸣圣水传递”活动的圣水采集仪式,在陕西省宝鸡市的岐山中国·周原(周公庙)景区成功举行。","pinyin":"qigongxinwen","name":"气功新闻","path":"/qigongxinwen"},{"id":837,"title":"青岛市非物质文化遗产传统武术交流赛开赛 ","short_title":"","img":null,"createdAt":"2023-04-23T10:48:36.000Z","description":" 4月22日,2023年青岛市非物质文化遗产传统武术交流赛第三、第四场预赛在西海岸城市传媒广场一楼开赛。","pinyin":"qigongxinwen","name":"气功新闻","path":"/qigongxinwen"},{"id":835,"title":"湖北省中医养生功法大赛决赛在武汉江滩成功举行","short_title":"","img":"https://p8.itc.cn/q_70/images03/20230422/f13c965c040f42ff9a19c2a048aa27a5.jpeg","createdAt":"2023-04-23T10:41:56.000Z","description":"4月21日,湖北省中医养生功法大赛决赛在美丽的武汉江滩举行,来自全省12支代表队齐聚长江边,纷纷亮出中医传统功法的绝活,让公众近距离欣赏了一场中医传统养生国粹的文化盛宴。","pinyin":"qigongxinwen","name":"气功新闻","path":"/qigongxinwen"}]

hot------>[{"id":179,"title":"【视频】第十届国际健康健美长寿论坛-首届世界大健康运动会","path":"/qigongxinwen"},{"id":13,"title":"十年成果回顾 精彩瞬间回放","path":"/qigongxinwen"},{"id":8,"title":"世界气功网开通","path":"/qigongxinwen"},{"id":477,"title":"天柱气功-刘少斌","path":"/qigongxinwen"},{"id":711,"title":"国际健康健美长寿论坛博览会暨世界大健康运动会简介","path":"/qigongxinwen"},{"id":428,"title":"清华大学校长施一公演讲,所谓“迷信”,可能是我们认知不到的超级科学! ","path":"/qigongxinwen"},{"id":184,"title":"第十一届国际健康健美长寿论坛博览会暨第二届世界大健康运动会将于2019年10月在日本东京举行","path":"/qigongxinwen"},{"id":712,"title":"世界大健康运动联盟词条","path":"/qigongxinwen"},{"id":257,"title":"太极开天地,气功贯东西——首届哈佛国际医学气功太极论坛在波士顿隆重召开","path":"/qigongxinwen"},{"id":199,"title":"郭周礼主席会见冷先锋并颁发聘书","path":"/qigongxinwen"}]

imgs------>[{"id":838,"title":"郭周礼主席出席周公庙润德泉圣水采集仪式并讲话","short_title":"","img":"https://p3-sign.toutiaoimg.com/tos-cn-i-qvj2lq49k0/a66e264d07e24f1c823bb63845f867e7~noop.image?_iz=58558&amp;from=article.pc_detail&amp;x-expires=1684845112&amp;x-signature=9c3BFi4%2BEgwATJ564g%2FlTYb6Hyw%3D","createdAt":"2023-05-16T12:49:36.000Z","description":"2023年5月15日,由世界大健康运动联盟发起,首届“五岳和鸣圣水传递”活动的圣水采集仪式,在陕西省宝鸡市的岐山中国·周原(周公庙)景区成功举行。","pinyin":"qigongxinwen","name":"气功新闻","path":"/qigongxinwen"},{"id":835,"title":"湖北省中医养生功法大赛决赛在武汉江滩成功举行","short_title":"","img":"https://p8.itc.cn/q_70/images03/20230422/f13c965c040f42ff9a19c2a048aa27a5.jpeg","createdAt":"2023-04-23T10:41:56.000Z","description":"4月21日,湖北省中医养生功法大赛决赛在美丽的武汉江滩举行,来自全省12支代表队齐聚长江边,纷纷亮出中医传统功法的绝活,让公众近距离欣赏了一场中医传统养生国粹的文化盛宴。","pinyin":"qigongxinwen","name":"气功新闻","path":"/qigongxinwen"},{"id":834,"title":"向第四届全国老年人体育健身大会致电祝贺","short_title":"","img":"http://img.shijieqigong.com/upload/2023/04/19/01.jpg","createdAt":"2023-04-19T14:17:16.000Z","description":"\n\n第十二届世界大健康论坛博览会暨第三届世界大健康运动会组委会\nThe 12th World Big Health Forum Expo and the Third Session of World Comprehensive Health Sports Meeting Organizing Committee\n贺 电\n尊敬的第四届全国老年人体育健身大会盛主席并全体代表:\n欣闻第四届全国老年人体育健身大会在四川泸州隆重举行, 谨代表世界大健康运动联盟和第十二届世界大健康论坛博览会暨第三届世界大健康运动会组","pinyin":"qigongxinwen","name":"气功新闻","path":"/qigongxinwen"},{"id":833,"title":"即将在澳门举办的大健康论坛博览会暨运动会筹备通知","short_title":"","img":"https://p3-sign.toutiaoimg.com/tos-cn-i-qvj2lq49k0/0722831f0ce04a3dab88695661c39074~noop.image?_iz=58558&amp;from=article.pc_detail&amp;x-expires=1682077001&amp;x-signature=yEXEgFq9s35ZnhgQ0hiY1DK0UUY%3D","createdAt":"2023-04-14T11:54:15.000Z","description":"第十二届世界大健康论坛·博览会暨第三届世界大健康运动会,定于 2023 年 9 月 12 日至 15 日在中国澳门举行。","pinyin":"qigongxinwen","name":"气功新闻","path":"/qigongxinwen"},{"id":832,"title":"退休医院院长泄露的20张机密图,张张能保命,快存下来!","short_title":"","img":"https://nimg.ws.126.net/?url=http%3A%2F%2Fdingyue.ws.126.net%2F2023%2F0406%2F4108b47aj00rso9ne002dc000f100k0m.jpg&amp;thumbnail=660x2147483647&amp;quality=80&amp;type=jpg","createdAt":"2023-04-06T13:32:31.000Z","description":"根据中医理论,人体内的经络就像一个纵横交错的交通网,联系着各大脏腑、沟通气血。","pinyin":"qigongxinwen","name":"气功新闻","path":"/qigongxinwen"}]

pre------>{"id":776,"title":"“气”话连篇63 | 秦及先秦“功业”建","name":"气功新闻","path":"/qigongxinwen"}

next------>{"id":778,"title":"“气”话连篇64 | 两汉时期“功绩”丰","name":"气功新闻","path":"/qigongxinwen"}